Turning an accidental signal into a $50k/week testing engine
Protect's top performers were simple talking-head ads about insurance. They were profitable โ but the brand didn't fully understand why, which made the wins hard to repeat with intent.
I went into the comments instead of the dashboard. Most engagement wasn't about insurance โ people were commenting that the presenter was beautiful. Surface-level, but that engagement fed the algorithm, which kept pushing the ad. So it was winning on a weak, accidental signal.
Replace it with a relevant signal tied to the buying decision, and the same mechanism pushes harder and far more durably.
- Led with insurance's most common myth โ that shopping around is slow and tedious โ to earn attention on a relevant hook.
- Kept that format as the template and rewrote the script to the audience's real objection.
- Productionised it with AI avatars so new messaging could be tested almost instantly.
- For a higher-income bracket, I protected the format and changed only the signalling โ a high-end setting + tuned script. It scaled to similar spend.